The USSR 23 Years On

stock-footage-soviet-union-flag-waving-in-the-windThe Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) ceased to exist exactly 23 years ago on December 26, 1991 by declaration no. 142-H of the Soviet of the Republics of the Supreme Soviet of the Soviet Union, acknowledging the independence of the 12 remaining republics of the Soviet Union, and creating the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS).

On the previous day, Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev, the eighth and last undisputed leader of the Soviet Union, had resigned, declared his office extinct, and handed over its attributes—including control of the Soviet nuclear missile launching codes—to Russian President Boris Yeltsin.

That evening at 7:32, the Soviet flag was lowered from the Kremlin for the last time and replaced with the Russian tricolor. From August to December, 13 of the 15 republics seceded from the union. The week before the union’s formal dissolution, 11 republics—all except the Baltic states and Georgia—signed the Alma-Ata Protocol formally establishing the CIS and declaring that the Soviet Union had ceased to exist. The dissolution of the Soviet Union also meant the end of the Cold War.

The Revolutions of 1989 and the end of the Soviet Union led to the end of decades of hostility between North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and the Warsaw Pact, which had been the defining feature of the Cold War.

The modern Russia now shares its western border with, from the north, Estonia, Latvia, Belarus and Ukraine then Georgia with Azerbaijan and Armenia are to the south west and separate the Russian Federation from Turkey.

These six countries are all that separate Russia from mainland Europe.

Although many of these countries suffered internal conflict in the aftermath of the breakup it had, on the whole, settled down. The buffer countries between Europe and Russia have become conduits to the massive trade between these two super powers. There is now an installed infrastructure connecting the Russian Federation to Europe by road, rail, pipeline, and wire and with it a lot of vested interest in keeping it all flowing smoothly.

Even with all that vested interest in harmony the compromise usually reached between the financial and political aspirations of the few has recently been out of balance. Most recently we have seen the Russian leader, Putin, shake his political fists at the world in what looks worryingly familiar to anyone who recalls Hitlers rise to power and desire to conquer the world.

When back in February the Ukrainian government fell apart under the pressure of their people who wanted the country to align with Europe while their leaders prepared to sign deals with Russia. Russia invaded Crimea.

The world, not wanting to upset the many vested interests, did nothing and Russia completed the annexation of Crimea with little or no opposition. The Ukrainian forces backed away in the face of overwhelming arrogance and formed a new front line in mainland Ukraine.

The UN, western leaders and the US swore a lot and banned the import of AK47s while still shipping everything from missile guidance systems to battleships to Russia. When Russia backed the “Ukrainian Nationalists” and invaded the south east of mainland Ukraine western powers distracted the world with other news stories in the hope that we would forget the on-going war in eastern Europe.

It was a moderate success and Putin continued to orchestrate the invasion of Ukraine while the world searched for MH370.

In truth the entire region, all those buffer countries and Poland were working with NATO to organize an escape from the threat of Russia.

On this auspicious day, the 23rd anniversary of the demise of the USSR and with it the end of the First Cold War we are on the brink of the second.

It is too late to suggest the UN should have honored the Budapest Memorandum and driven Russia out of Crimea. It is too late for the nearly 5,000 people who have died in Ukraine in the last 10 months. It may be to late too stop the Second Cold War.

And lets face it, those with the power to stop this from happening have a vested interest in a Second Cold War, most of those who could intervene are share holders in the security and weapons companies that will thrive in the Second Cold War. For them the wealth of a few is more important than the lives of so many.


Crimean Tatars Homes are Marked in Ukraine

CRIMEA-LEAFLET-JEWSThe situation inside Ukraine has become increasingly difficult to discern. Certainly in the last few weeks the majority of the reports published have come from the US, Russia and UN and very little from within Ukraine.

That all changed a few days ago with this leaflet, first published by the USA Today. I shall not repeat the story, you can read it in its original form if you follow the link.

The content is extremely disturbing. It echoes of Nazi propaganda in the run up to WW2 and for this reason I felt it had to be questioned so I asked my correspondent in Kiev for his view.

This is what he said;

This one looks like a hoax to me. But I won’t be surprised if anti-Semitic actions will take place their. Pro-Russian propaganda is really heavy their. For example:
  1. In prime time news narrator tells that “Great Russia is again respected. It’s the only country that can turn the USA into the radioactive dust.”
  2. Putin in his news conference warns that all journalists/activists who have a position different from the government are “national-traitors” (a term actively used by Hitler).
  3. The propaganda lays the blame on the Ukrainian government and tells us they are fascists. In reality there were a lot of Jews on Maidan who died fighting for the current leaders.
  4. The current governor of the central region is Ihor Kolomoisky. He offered rewards yesterday for AKMs (1000 usd), machine-guns (~1500 usd) and captured Russian soldiers (10.000 usd).
Again I doubt there are any documents that prove such behaviour of pro-Russian activists, but from what I know they blame the Jews for supporting Ukrainian revolutions.
Finally I know that pro-Russian activists have marked the houses of Crimean Tatars in the same way the doors of Jewish households were marked with a red cross in the build up to WW2

Tell me, what part of this do you find most disturbing? To me, the similarities to the situation that prevailed before the outbreak of war in Europe in 1939 and before that, in 1914 is striking. We have all the ingredients required to spark war.

For those who think this isn’t possible, that a modern cultivated Europe, the UN, with all its education, history and wealth, war in Europe could not happen again, I remind you that what we now call WW1 was simply known as the “War in Europe” or “The Great War” until WW2 started.

A Letter From Kiev

01bccd9f-dce8-45e9-b0cb-7f528aa4f921_16x9_788x442Along with this personal commentary I maintain a constant reportage resource of news concerning the troubles in Ukraine. Initially news was flooding out of Kiev at such a rate it was hard to keep up with it but over the last week the news feed has dried up.

Now I actively search every day for updates from the news agencies and from my friends and contacts in Kiev. When there are multiple sources it is easy to route out the truth from the propaganda but as the flow reduces, the truth is harder to find.

I received an email from a friend in Kiev last night, he said;

  • “It’s pretty worrisome here, but we try to remain positive. From news I hear about a lot of Russian troops near borders, but I doubt they will move to mainland Ukraine. It will mean WW3. Though if you watch Russian news – it looks like they actually want to start a war. I’ve never though I would see much a heavy propaganda in our century. And the worst thing that people in Russia believe this propaganda. I hope for the best. This situation is a good test for UN and other organizations.”

Looking for verification of his report of troops near the border we found this quote from a top Ukrainian defence official on Thursday he said

  • “Almost 100,000 Russian troops have amassed on Ukraine’s border”

This figure is much higher than U.S. military estimates.

Andriy Parubiy, chairman of Ukraine’s national security council, said via webcast from Kiev.

  • “Russian troops aren’t in Crimea only. They’re along all Ukrainian borders. They’re in the south, the east and the north,”
  • “Russia is plotting to incite separatist sentiment in other areas after its successful intervention in the Crimea region” He told the Atlantic Council, a Washington-based think tank.

The deployed forces are well-trained special forces, he said, adding that Kiev fears a potential Russian invasion of the country’s east any day now.

Meanwhile a senior U.S. defense official on condition of anonymity expressed scepticism at Parubiy’s estimate of the number of Russian forces saying;

  • “That sounds too high,” he told Agence France Presse;
  • “The Pentagon said more than 20,000 Russian troops have been deployed along the border with Ukraine, included airborne units and armored vehicles.”

Parubiy said his country supported the sanctions against Russia imposed by Western countries, and appealed for visible military support, a visible presence of our partnership to send a signal to Moscow over its actions.

  • “We’re calling on our partners to hold a common military exercise” that would “show that the cooperation and partnership is still there,” he said.

Other reports circulating this evening would lead us to believe the UN with NATO are actively monitoring the situation to the west of Russia with surveillance aircraft but they did not say weather that coverage extended to the Ukraine – Russia border. I suspect it does not for fear of a US spy plane being shot down by the Russians, again.

At best the Second Cold War has its icy grip on us. At worst we have all the ingredients of WW3.

Are The U.S. and the E.U. Deliberately Assisting Russia?

Dateline: Thursday 20th March 2014

U.S. and E.U. officials are meeting today to discuss possible further sanctions over the Russian occupation of Crimea. Sanctions so far enacted are limited to financial and visa restrictions on some 25 Russian individuals.

I wrote in The Art Of War about how military or political tacticians usually planned all possible options well in advance and kept those plans secret. In fact secrecy is an essential component of all success in this context.

The officials meeting in Brussels must be familiar with these concepts so what I do not understand is why are they meeting now, after the fact, and why are they telling the world what they are doing?

Or not doing. This may be closer to the point. So far the political tactic seems to be one of public inactivity and incompetence and when actions are to be taken plenty of warning is given to the aggressor.

This can only be explained one of two ways; Either the U.S. and the E.U. are deliberately assisting Russia in their mission to absorb Crimea or they are genuinely stupid.

I am not sure what I would prefer to believe. Either way it begs the question of where Putin will stop on his march across Europe. The Russian propaganda machine will use almost any argument if it gets them what they want.

crimea-referendum_2850933bFor example they used this poster in Crimea in the days before the referendum, the outline is Crimea, the message reads [Nazis] Or [Russia].

The Russian argument for supporting the occupation [and supply of unmarked troops] in Crimea is ethnic Russians living there need protection [from what?]. And they are preparing to use this argument for their occupation of Ukraine.

The Russian propaganda machine has also indicated they are concerned about the welfare of their nationals in Poland.

I ask again, why are the people who could do something about this doing noting?

The Crimea Referendum or; How To March Across Europe

UKRAINE-RUSSIA-POLITICS-UNREST-CRIMEA-TROOPSAs I write this the Crimea Referendum is taking place 1,460 miles to the east of me. A vote proposed at gun point only ten days ago.

I am speechless at the lack of decisive action taken by the UN, Europe or the US. The Ukraine have been left to fend for themselves while the powers who were supposed to protect their sovereignty have done nothing except make woolly threats.

While those that could help have done nothing Russia has continued its occupation of Crimea, Ukrainians have continued to die and the world has been distracted by the missing Malaysian 777 flight MH370.

I have one laptop permanently open on the news tickers looking for new reports coming out of Ukraine, Crimea or Russia but there is noting. I was planning on writing about how the referendum was just a distraction while Russia massed it troops but if it was they didn’t need it. No one is paying any attention. The ostrich politics practised here is something I thought only the UK government played but when it comes to the troubles in Ukraine it seems the whole world is just hoping if they ignore it , it might go away.

The problem is, it wont go away. Ignoring the problem or talking sanctions will simply have all parties involve retreating into ‘cold war’ politics while in Ukraine they will have real war with guns, bullets, bombs, tanks and many, many dead.

Real war and death. Just days ago I speculated that should the UN do nothing to prevent it Russia would continue to march across Ukraine as soon as they felt Crimea was secure, it is perfectly logical.

“How to march across Europe”

  1. Occupy a soft, friendly target [Crimea] to test the resolve of the enemy.
  2. Occupy the surrounding ‘buffer’ countries [Ukraine] to protect your new citizens.
  3. If stage 1 and 2 were completed with little or no resistance then continue across Europe.

As I write this stage one is complete and stage two has begun.

Putin Continues to Suppress Opposition Voices

logoIn Russia Putin continues to suppress opposition voices. Reuters have just reported that Russia has blocked access to the web sites of prominent Kremlin foes Alexei Navalny and Garry Kasparov.

Alexi writes a blog here which to us in the free press would seem mild and harmless. Garry [the chess player], announced his retirement from professional chess on 10 March 2005, so that he could devote his time to politics and writing. He formed the United Civil Front movement, and joined as a member of The Other Russia, a coalition opposing the administration and policies of Vladimir Putin.

Neither man has done anything that would land them in jail in the UK, Europe or the US but their voices in Russia are loud enough to disturb Putins sleep.

What are they trying to stop the Russian people being exposed to? Things like this by Vitaly Portnikov; [paraphrased after translation]

  • My Grandmother used to tell me about the evacuation. Then, when I was little, I could not understand the tragedy. Now, when I talk with my friends or just read letters from unfamiliar Crimean people on social networks, I understand what it is – and I also know that this can happen at any time to me and my loved ones if the aggressor moves on.

If you are reading this in Russia and can not access the online content you seek leave a comment below telling me what you want to see and I will re-post it here for you.

Empty Threats

russia-ukraine-senate-address.siSo, what are you going to do then? The Russians have occupied Crimea, told the world they have a right to be there and refused to discuss it. They have their feet under the table.

Meanwhile European leaders and the US are running around like the proverbial ‘headless chickens’ making empty threats. No wonder the Russians are comfortable.

Does anyone know what EU Sanction Phase II is? what was Phase I and what will Phase III be? I don’t and to be fair I doubt Putin knows either, or cares. I looked it up but found nothing. I asked and I am still waiting for a reply, I guess they don’t know either.

All we have to go in is what the EU Leaders are saying. So this is what we ‘know’ about Phase II;

  • It might commence on Monday.
  • It might include visa restrictions.
  • It might include asset freezing.
  • It might include cancelling meetings.

Honestly, I can see Putin backing off with those ‘threats’, not. If that is Phase II I wonder what Phase III might include?

  • Not allowing flights into Russia?
  • Not paying the bill for oil and gas imports?
  • Getting very red faced and stamping our feet?

Come on people, do something!

Who is Making The Decisions Round Here?

maylasia_2848220bA plane has gone missing and suddenly the focus of the news has moved to panoramic shots of unblemished blue ocean. Meanwhile “Russian” forces continue to entrench in Crimea and armed units test the resolve of the Ukrainian border guards.

I checked the news, the agencies and all the other sources I could find. In the last hour I found some 13,000 reports world wide on the subject of Crimea, Russia and the Ukraine, they all said something, and they all said nothing. In summary this is what I found;

  • …Ukraine’s interim leaders established a new National Guard on Tuesday and appealed to the United States and Britain for assistance…
  • …Crimea peninsula voted on Tuesday for full independence from Ukraine in preparation for a referendum to join Russia…
  • …Ukraine’s parliament on Tuesday appealed to Washington and London, urging them to utilise all “diplomatic, political, economic and military” means to counter Russian intervention on the Crimean…
  • …diplomatic efforts to resolve the dispute over Ukraine stalled…
  • …European Union would impose sanctions on Russia starting from Monday…

The question in the title of this essay is now posed; Who is making the decisions round here? It seems to me the answer to that is “no one”.

There is no “champion”, no one standing up calling the shots, no one demanding mobilisation, no one seems to want to take responsibility for what is clearly a situation grown out of apathy.

I know the choices are between a “rock and a hard place” but Europe, the UN and the USA must act soon or Russia will simply continue with its march across Europe. They feel justified in protecting ethnic Russians in Crimea right now, next week, after the referendum they will occupy south and east Ukraine to defend their borders and the supplies of fuel, electricity and water to the Crimea peninsula.

Retaliation by Ukrainian defence forces will commence, UN forces will be legally obliged to join the Ukrainians in accordance with the Budapest Memorandum and the third European war will have started.

Or we could do nothing. Does anyone know how long it takes a modern army to march across Ukraine, Poland and into Germany? Or Hungary into Austria, Slovenia, Italy and into France?


Deadline March 16

 A Ukrainian protester stands at a memorial for the people killed in clashes at Kiev's Independence Square, on March 1. The focus of Ukraine's crisis is now in Crimea, where Russian forces are effectively in control. Emilio Morenatti/AP

A Ukrainian protester stands at a memorial for the people killed in clashes at Kiev’s Independence Square, on March 1. The focus of Ukraine’s crisis is now in Crimea, where Russian forces are effectively in control. Emilio Morenatti/AP

The autonomous government of Crimea and Sevastopol’s City Council, with the backing of the occupying Russians are planning to hold a referendum on March 16th. The poll will ask two questions of the people of Crimea;

  • Are you in favour of Crimea becoming a constituent territory of the Russian Federation?
  • Are you in favour of restoring Crimea’s 1992 constitution?

The first is UDI and a request to Russia for support. The second is a return to the pre occupation state.

Seems simple doesn’t it? But the population of Crimea is Russian, all bar the shouting. They carry Russian passports, they speak Russian, they look East for support and they will, without a doubt vote UDI.

In that case the Russians will feel justified in reinforcing their border with Ukraine and if they consider the unstable political state of Ukraine a threat they will simply extend their occupation beyond their borders to build a buffer zone, still Ukrainian but occupied and controlled by Russia.

The argument that the referendum is illegal or unconstitutional or will not be recognised is irrelevant, if it goes ahead two million Crimeans will become Russians, they will have exercised their democratic right, legal or not, and I can not imagine the West telling them they can not have their wish.

Their only other option is war and it is clear they do not want to go there. Except…

Europeans are withdrawing their embassy staff from Crimea, Russians in the west are having their visas revoked and are being sent home, troops are massing on both sides of the Ukraine and flexing their muscles. The world is preparing for war between the UN and Russia.

No, don’t even think it. This would be a new European war, the Third World War, the flea that breaks the back of the UN agreement signed seventy years ago to prevent exactly this from happening.

Intervention is required before March 16th.